Go to Main Website

If football is our national game, how long will it remain so when the English and Scottish professional leagues are stuffed with overseas players? And now the Premiership wants to play games outside of Britain...

Give capitalism enough room and it will wreck any industry – even football

WORKERS, MAR 2008 ISSUE

Why are there so many overseas football players in the English and Scottish professional leagues? There were always many Scots and Welsh with English clubs and Irish in both leagues, but few moved outside that circle. In some games in the Premier League 15 or more players from abroad are on the pitch. Even in Scotland and the English lower divisions there are many overseas players, in a far greater proportion than occurs in other countries.

The number of overseas players grew slowly for 30 years until the Premiership was introduced in 1992. It increased rapidly thereafter, as did the number of televised games and satellite TV revenues.

Yet it's not only the players that have changed, many other factors have combined to undermine the national aspect of football. The Premier League's plan to play the "39th game" abroad is ill conceived, and farcical. Michel Platini said, "It's ironic. You already have no English coach, you have no English players and maybe now you will have no clubs playing in England. It's a joke." There's an element of truth in that. The plan is part of a wider pattern, along with the Bosman ruling that allowed players freedom of contract, and the increase in foreign, debt-based ownership.

The national game?
Once football was always called the national game; everyone watched and played it. Depending on your point of view, it represented a Corinthian ideal of sporting activity or a release from everyday drudgery. Now we hear that the game is too commercial and (again depending on your view) it either sets the wrong example to Britain's youth, or is an object lesson in the consequences of excessive greed.

The truth is less clear-cut and more interesting. Greed was never far away among club owners. Players showed determination and solidarity to form the Professional Footballers Association (PFA) a century ago, and 55 years later broke the maximum wage rule. Professional players were rarely high-minded, but practical in wanting to protect themselves and earn a better share of the money flowing into clubs. The PFA is still strong today, in a very different era. Despite the high profile of some PFA members, most of its work is done with and for players who never make the headlines.

Players also wanted an end to the "contract and retain" system, which left them no say in where they played. It did not come about from a fight with British clubs or leagues. It was the unintended consequence of a court action by one player, Marc Bosman, against his (unreasonable) club. Helped by European Union laws on the mobility of labour, the effect was to give freedom of contract to players for the first time. Clubs could no longer keep players against their will.

What developed was a system where there was an incentive for clubs and agents to move players on before contracts expired, to make money on transfers. And it permitted clubs to bring in players without restriction from anywhere in the EU (or from elsewhere if a suitable passport could be secured). Players, nominally free to move, are still controlled by someone else, even though paid beyond the dreams of earlier generations.

The PFA in its Centenary Year has produced the "Meltdown Report" – an indictment of the decline in home-based professional players over the past 15 years. This decline was well known, but the PFA research shows it is even greater than generally realised. The report says, "The bottom line is a very simple one. Older ready-made foreign players are blocking young English players' path into the Premier League". That's true also for players from Wales, Scotland and Ireland, according to the evidence in the report.

The number of regular English players in the top division is just under 50 per cent of the 1992/93 level – and nearer to 35 per cent for other home players. The report concentrates on the Premiership; but the same applies to clubs in lower divisions. All are now so afraid of failure that they have neither the time nor ability to develop players or teams in the way that other countries have done. Clubs spend a great deal on training younger players, and then throw it away in the pursuit of instant success. Such expenditure does not necessarily mean a commitment to development.

The Football Association tried to reform junior coaching and football careers. It encouraged clubs to set up academies, and then imposed a rule limiting travelling distances. That was not motivated by concerns for youth players' welfare, but was an attempt to stop top clubs taking all the promising juniors. Lower league clubs saw it as a way of securing transfer fees that were disappearing as more overseas imports arrived. Again, there was little thought behind the immediate gain. This was exacerbated as money from TV grew for the Premiership, but melted away for others after ITV Sport folded.

Since hostile takeover of Manchester United in 2005, financed by a huge level of debt, other top clubs have become the target for similar finance-driven buy-outs. Each time this happens the pressure for immediate success increases, as does the attraction of a European League, free of regulation by national governing bodies and having to play "lesser" teams.

The cheap money driving those deals is drying up; it's hard to see what will happen other than forced sales or squeezing more money out of supporters and TV. That in turn will increase the pressures that led to the current level of imported players.

Football in a country that uniquely has two major professional leagues and an unmatched depth of professional clubs will be transformed. The successful clubs are debt-ridden and forced to hawk themselves around the world to pay off their banks. And the rest are slowly contracting, moving further away from the game that everyone played and watched. Young players who might have had a career in football are becoming more and more likely to drift out of the game, the prospect of a brief appearance in the reserves being the most they can expect to achieve.

top